The Two Tellings: Homeric Hymn and Orphic Fragment

The Homeric Hymn to Demeter, generally dated to the seventh or sixth century BCE and among the oldest substantial sources for the Eleusinian material, gives the role of breaking Demeter's grief to a figure named Iambe, who succeeds through jokes and verbal wit rather than through any physical gesture, a scene decorous enough to sit comfortably within a hymn meant for public religious performance. The alternative telling, in which the figure is named Baubo and lifts her skirt to expose herself, provoking Demeter to laugh despite her grief, survives only in Orphic poetic fragments, and those fragments are known almost entirely because the early Christian writer Clement of Alexandria quoted them in his Protrepticus specifically in order to mock and discredit pagan mystery religion.

Relying on a hostile source for the sole surviving version of a story is a serious limitation on what can be said about it: Clement had every reason to select and frame the most scandalous version available to him, and no sympathetic or neutral quotation of the Orphic Baubo passage survives to check his framing against. The gesture itself, lifting the skirt to reveal the body as a means of provoking laughter, has a name in later scholarship, anasyrma, and is documented in a small number of other ancient contexts as well, including an account in Herodotus describing Egyptian religious festival practice, which suggests the underlying gesture was not confined to the Eleusinian material alone even if Baubo herself is known from nowhere else.