Divinity Atlas

Sacred Correspondences
Articles

A Line the Historian Doubted

Citation Formats

General Reference

APA Style

BibTeX

Learn More
A Line the Historian Doubted

The chapter ends on a sentence that had a long career in Chinese literature: the way of heaven has no favourites and is constantly with the good.

Its most famous appearance outside this book is in the great historical record compiled by Sima Qian in the Han period. In the account of Bo Yi and Shu Qi, two brothers who refused to serve a new dynasty they judged illegitimate and starved on a mountain rather than eat its grain, the historian quotes this line and then asks whether it can be true. Men of the highest conduct died of hunger, and men of no scruple lived long and prosperous lives, and he says plainly that he is perplexed and wonders whether what is called the way of heaven is right or not.

That is one of the most direct challenges to a religious proposition in early Chinese writing, and it is put by quoting this chapter against itself.

The line is also in tension with chapter five of this book, which says heaven and earth are not humane and treat the ten thousand things as straw dogs, the figures made for a ritual and discarded once it is over. A heaven with no favourites that is nonetheless constantly with the good is not obviously the same heaven that is indifferent.

The book contains both statements and reconciles neither. Readers who want a moral order have this chapter, readers who want an impersonal one have chapter five, and the two have been set against each other for as long as the text has been read.

Cross-Tradition Connections

Article On

Sources
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.

View At A Past Year

The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.