Divinity Atlas

Sacred Correspondences
Religious Roles & Titles

Monk

Christianity Roles

Citation Formats

General Reference

APA Style

BibTeX

Origin 270 to 400 CE

A monk is bound by vows, and the vows rather than any ordination are what constitute the office. In the Benedictine tradition the vows are stability, obedience and conversion of life, stability meaning attachment to one particular house for life, a Benedictine joins a monastery, not an order. Later orders formulated the vows as poverty, chastity and obedience. A monk is a layman unless separately ordained, and most monastic communities have always contained both ordained and lay members; the choir monk who is a priest and the lay brother who is not hold the same monastic status.

Vows are taken in stages, temporary before solemn, and the delay is deliberate. Solemn vows can be dispensed by church authority, which is a narrow and formal process rather than a resignation. In Orthodox monasticism the tonsure marks entry and the grades run from rassophore to the great schema. Monastic life is enclosed to varying degrees, and the strictest houses, Carthusian, and the more austere Cistercian foundations, keep an enclosure that most people, including most Catholics, never see the inside of.

Facts
Organisation
Ordination
Restricted to men 2Tradition: Christian monasticism
A community of men
Ordination
Celibacy required of the ordained 3Tradition: Christian monasticism
Ordination
Ordination is into a monastic order, not to a congregation 3Tradition: Christian monasticism
Entered by monastic profession, not by ordination to a congregation
Attributions
Tradition
Christianity, chiefly Catholic and Orthodox monasticism 1
Origins
Origin Period
270 to 400 CE 2
Status
Status Today
Living tradition, practised today 2
Learn More
The Office Made by Vows, Not by Ordination

A monk is bound by vows, and it is the vows rather than any ordination that constitute the office, a point that distinguishes the monastic life from the priesthood.

Bound by profession

In the Benedictine tradition the vows are of stability, of obedience, and of conversion of life, which encompasses celibacy and the renunciation of private property, and a man becomes a monk by professing them within a community, not by being ordained, so that many monks are not priests and the two states are distinct. The monk life is ordered around the round of communal prayer, the work of the community, and the seeking of God within the enclosure, under a rule and an abbot.

A wide and old ideal

Entry is by a period of testing, the novitiate, followed by profession, first for a term and then for life, so the office is entered gradually and by free commitment. The monastic ideal is far older and wider than Christianity: the Buddhist bhikkhu bound by the monastic code, the Hindu and Jain renunciant, and the monks of other traditions represent the same fundamental impulse, the withdrawal from ordinary life under vows for the sake of a spiritual end. What the Christian monk shares with these is the constitution of the office by renunciation and vow rather than by any sacramental order, the monk being first of all one who has professed a way of life.

From the Egyptian Desert to a Shrinking Western Population

Christian monasticism began in the deserts of Egypt in the late third and fourth centuries, with hermits such as Anthony withdrawing alone and Pachomius shortly after organising the first communal monasteries with a shared rule, an innovation that made monastic life reproducible rather than dependent on one extraordinary individual. Basil of Caesarea shaped the communal model that became standard in the Greek East, while Benedict of Nursia's sixth century rule, moderate by the standards of the harshest desert asceticism, became the near-universal template for Western monasticism for the following thousand years.

Medieval Western monasticism went through repeated cycles of reform, the tenth century Cluniac reform centralising hundreds of houses under one abbey, the Cistercians reacting against that same wealth and centralisation in the twelfth century with a return to austerity and manual labour, and each new order in turn accumulating land and influence that a later reform movement would react against. The English Reformation's dissolution of the monasteries under Henry VIII in the 1530s eliminated the office almost entirely in one country within a few years, a scale of sudden loss with no real parallel elsewhere in Western monastic history. Monastic vocations in Western Europe and North America have fallen steeply since the 1960s, while communities in parts of Africa and Asia have grown, a pattern that broadly mirrors vocations to the priesthood and religious life generally.

Cross-Tradition Connections

Associated With

A monk of Sarov, never a superior and holding no office.

Eldership arises inside monastic life and is exercised by monks of no rank as readily as by superiors.

Source The Orthodox ChurchTimothy Ware (Kallistos Ware)

Belongs to Tradition

Element Of

Anglicanism, Denominations

The English religious houses were dissolved at the Reformation, and Anglican religious life was refounded in the nineteenth century. It exists and is honoured, and it is required of no one.

Held, and the Armenian monasteries were the centres in which the manuscript inheritance of the church was written and kept.

Source The Armenian People From Ancient to Modern TimesRichard G. Hovannisian (ed.)

Egyptian monasticism is where Christian monasticism began, and the desert houses of Wadi Natrun have been occupied almost without a break since the fourth century.

Source Two Thousand Years of Coptic ChristianityOtto F. A. Meinardus

Orthodox monasticism is not divided into orders. A monk belongs to his monastery, and the Athonite houses are the pattern.

Source The Orthodox ChurchTimothy Ware (Kallistos Ware)

Ethiopian monasticism is large and old, and its houses have been the principal carriers of the church learning.

Source Two Thousand Years of Coptic ChristianityOtto F. A. Meinardus

Western monasticism is governed by a rule, most often that of Benedict, and the monk vows stability, obedience and conversion of life to a particular house.

Source The Rule of Saint BenedictBenedict of Nursia

Rejected Here

Baptist, Denominations

Refused, since Baptist churches hold that no state of life is more consecrated than another and that the ordinary Christian calling is lived in the world.

Calvinism (Reformed), Denominations

Refused in the Reformed churches, which held the monastic life to rest on a false distinction between counsel and commandment.

Source The Westminster Confession of FaithWestminster Assemblythe holders' own account
Lutheranism, Denominations

The Augsburg Confession treats monastic vows at length and refuses them, holding that they were presented as a way of earning grace and that the Lutheran territories were right to dissolve the houses.

Friends have no vowed religious life, and the refusal follows from the same conviction that refuses a separated clergy.

Instances

How this title is used in the Roman Catholic Church.

Sources
1. The Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church, 3rd revised edition
F. L. Cross and E. A. Livingstone (eds.), Oxford University Press, 2005on Christian monasticismView the Source
2. Medieval Monasticism: Forms of Religious Life in Western Europe in the Middle Ages
C. H. Lawrence, Longman, 2001On stability and the shape of Western monastic lifeView the Source
2. Medieval Monasticism: Forms of Religious Life in Western Europe in the Middle Ages
C. H. Lawrence, Longman, 2001on the monk and the vowsView the Source
3. RB 1980: The Rule of St. Benedict in Latin and English with Notes
Timothy Fry (ed.), Liturgical Press, 1981Chapters 58 and 59: the reception of brothers and the vows
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.

View At A Past Year

Choose a year to see this entry's facts and connections as the atlas records them at that moment: what it held then, what it held instead, and what it had not yet adopted. Choose Present for the current record.