Rituals
Dakhma Exposure (Tower of Silence)
Also Known As Tower of Silence (English)Original Term Dokhmenashini
Funerary Rituals
Citation Formats
General Reference
APA Style
BibTeX
Origin Attested from the Sasanian period, with earlier Iranian exposure practice reported by classical writers
Dakhma exposure, dokhmenashini, is the Zoroastrian funerary rite in which the dead are laid in a dakhma, a raised circular structure called in English a tower of silence, to be consumed by vultures and the sun, because earth, fire and water are sacred creations that a corpse, the most polluting of things, must not defile. The rite continues at the dakhmas of Mumbai, while Iranian Zoroastrians abandoned dakhma use in the twentieth century in favour of burial, and its future is debated among Parsis: the collapse of South Asian vulture populations from the 1990s broke the system's ecological base, and the community argues over solar concentrators, aviaries, burial and cremation as continuations or departures.
Facts
Disputed
ObligationObligatory 3Tradition: Zoroastrianism John R. Hinnells's The Zoroastrian Diaspora: Religion and Migration, Oxford University Press, 2005, documents how the South Asian vulture population collapse of the 1990s, caused by the veterinary drug diclofenac, removed the ecological mechanism the dakhma exposure rite depends on at the Indian Towers of Silence, since the rite requires vultures to consume the exposed body. Hinnells's method is documentary and sociological, tracing the community's response to that ecological failure, and it finds the community divided rather than resolved: orthodox voices hold exposure is the only lawful method regardless of the practical difficulty, while reformist voices accept cremation or burial as alternatives. The debate over which position governs the community remains ongoing, and the atlas records it without adjudicating. Obligation DetailPrescribed disposal in orthodox practice; whether exposure can continue, and what may replace it, is debated among Parsis 3Tradition: Zoroastrianism John R. Hinnells's The Zoroastrian Diaspora: Religion and Migration, Oxford University Press, 2005, documents how the South Asian vulture population collapse of the 1990s, caused by the veterinary drug diclofenac, removed the ecological mechanism the dakhma exposure rite depends on at the Indian Towers of Silence, since the rite requires vultures to consume the exposed body. Hinnells's method is documentary and sociological, tracing the community's response to that ecological failure, and it finds the community divided rather than resolved: orthodox voices hold exposure is the only lawful method regardless of the practical difficulty, while reformist voices accept cremation or burial as alternatives. The debate over which position governs the community remains ongoing, and the atlas records it without adjudicating. Current StatusIn decline and disputed within the Parsi community following the collapse of South Asian vulture populations from the 1990s; largely abandoned earlier among Iranian Zoroastrians 1Tradition: Zoroastrianism Dakhma exposure, excarnation of the dead atop a Tower of Silence to be consumed by vultures and the elements, is the traditional Zoroastrian funerary practice Mary Boyce documents in Zoroastrians: Their Religious Beliefs and Practices (1979) as resting on the principle that a corpse is ritually impure and must not contaminate earth, fire or water. India's vulture population collapsed from the 1990s due to a veterinary drug toxic to the birds, leaving towers without their traditional means of excarnation and forcing the community to respond. Traditionalist and reform-minded Parsi authorities disagree over the response: some support solar concentrators installed to accelerate decomposition without fire or burial, while others hold that cremation or burial, though contrary to the traditional principle, has become the more practicable accommodation. The method by which this is documented is contemporary religious-community reporting rather than historical reconstruction, since the dispute concerns a live response to a recent ecological crisis. Because the underlying principle is not in question and only the practical response is disputed, the current status is recorded as debated rather than settled. Origins
Origin PeriodAttested from the Sasanian period, with earlier Iranian exposure practice reported by classical writers 1Tradition: Zoroastrianism Place of Origin Historical OriginThis survey of Zoroastrian belief and practice traces the custom to the tradition's concern with keeping the sacred elements of earth and fire free from the pollution of a corpse, exposing the body on a raised platform instead of burying or burning it. 1 Practice
Who Performs ItTrained or authorised specialists 1 FrequencyOnce, or at a turning point in a life 1 Meaning
Literal MeaningZoroastrians: Their Religious Beliefs and Practices explains dakhma as the Avestan term for the raised platform of exposure, colloquially known in English as the Tower of Silence, where the Zoroastrian dead were traditionally left rather than buried or cremated. 1 Attributions
PurposeGrounded in the Zoroastrian teaching that a corpse is ritually impure and must never contaminate the sacred elements of earth, fire or water, so the body is instead exposed on a raised platform for the elements and scavenging birds to consume. 1 Function
Stage of Life MarkedDeath and the disposal of the body 1 Learn More
Keeping the Sacred Elements Pure
Zoroastrian theology treats earth, fire and water as sacred creations that must not be contaminated by contact with a corpse, which the tradition regards as a locus of nasu, a spiritual impurity or corrupting force believed to take hold of the body at the moment of death, a concern the tradition treats as ritually and cosmologically serious rather than merely practical.
Burial and cremation, the two most common funerary methods elsewhere in the world, are both therefore judged to defile a sacred element, earth or fire, and traditional Zoroastrian practice developed dakhma exposure, dokhmenashini, as the method that avoids both, exposing the body instead in a specially constructed dakhma, a raised circular structure with no roof, popularly known in English as a tower of silence, so that the flesh is consumed by scavenging birds and the sun rather than committed to earth, fire or water. The remains, once skeletonised, were traditionally understood to be sufficiently free of nasu that the bones could then be placed without further concern in a central ossuary pit within the structure itself, completing the funerary process without any of the sacred elements having been directly touched by the corrupting matter of death.
A Practice in Decline and Dispute
Dakhma exposure has become substantially harder to sustain in recent decades, chiefly because of a catastrophic, well documented collapse in South Asian vulture populations from the 1990s onward, caused by the veterinary drug diclofenac entering the food chain through livestock carcasses, which removed the birds the practice depends on to complete the process quickly and left bodies at some towers of silence, particularly in Mumbai, decomposing far more slowly and visibly than the tradition intends. That ecological crisis has forced the Parsi community, the Zoroastrian community of India descended from migrants from Iran, into difficult and genuinely divided debate over how to respond, with some authorities supporting solar concentrators to accelerate decomposition and others, more reluctantly, accepting cremation or burial for at least some of their dead, a shift traditionalists within the community have opposed as a departure from correctly maintained practice.
Iranian Zoroastrians largely abandoned dakhma exposure earlier, under twentieth century government pressure and changing urban conditions, shifting mostly to burial in concrete lined graves designed to minimise earth contact, a compromise solution distinct from the towers of silence still standing, though increasingly contested in their use, in India today. The practice remains a live and unresolved point of internal Zoroastrian debate rather than a settled question either way.
Cross-Tradition Connections
Associated With
The dakhmas of Mumbai remain in use among Parsis, whose community argues over solar concentrators, aviaries, burial and cremation as the ecological base for vulture exposure has collapsed.
Belongs to Tradition
Related To
Sources
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.
Sign in to dispute this or suggest a correction.
View At A Past Year
The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.