No Mithraic scripture, theological treatise or internal account of the cult's beliefs survives, a silence that sets Mithraism apart from nearly every other tradition described in this section and makes the physical mithraeum, along with its inscriptions, reliefs and associated artifacts, the primary evidence scholars have for reconstructing what initiates actually believed and did. A widely accepted reconstruction, built up from mosaic floor inscriptions at the mithraeum beneath Santa Prisca and comparable evidence elsewhere, identifies seven grades of initiation, each associated with a planetary deity and a distinct symbolic animal or object, through which a member progressed over time, suggesting an organized structure of graduated religious advancement broadly comparable in principle, though not in specific content, to systems found in other ancient mystery cults.
The communal meal taken on the mithraeum's benches, evidenced by animal bone deposits and cooking installations found at excavated sites, appears to have functioned as a central ritual practice binding a mithraeum's small membership together, membership that, unusually among the traditions covered here, was restricted to men and drew especially heavily from Roman soldiers, merchants and imperial administrative staff, groups whose mobility across the empire likely explains how thoroughly similar mithraea, and the standardized tauroctony image at their center, spread from Britain to the eastern Mediterranean. The cult did not survive the Christianization of the Roman Empire in the fourth century, and its mithraea were abandoned, deliberately damaged, or built over, leaving archaeology rather than continuous tradition as the sole route back to what once happened inside them.