This is Pierre Dor's historical study of the Tunic of Argenteuil, written to correct assumptions about the relic's history using several then-unpublished documents the author located relating to its documented history between 1156 and 1486, and to set that history against the rival claim made for the Holy Robe of Trier, the book's explicit second subject named in its own subtitle. Its strength is archival: it works from newly located primary documents rather than restating the traditional legend. Its limit is that it was published by a small regional history press in the Anjou region of France rather than a major academic publisher, and the author's independence from the Argenteuil parish that holds the relic has not been established by the atlas, so its account of the rivalry is read here as informative rather than as a disinterested arbitration of which claim is stronger. This page's record previously carried a fabricated title, author and publisher matching no real publication; it is corrected here to this real study, verified against independent bibliographic listings of the book's title, author, publisher, year, page count and ISBN.
Facts
Assessment
Reliability Tier2
A single-author historical monograph drawing on newly located archival documents (relating to the relic's documented history between 1156 and 1486) rather than restating the traditional legend, published by a small regional history press in the Anjou region of France rather than a major academic publisher. The author's institutional independence from the Argenteuil parish that holds the relic has not been established by the atlas, so the tier reflects real archival scholarship read with appropriate caution about advocacy. NotesPierre Dor, La Tunique d'Argenteuil et ses pretendues rivales: etude historique (Maulevrier: Editions Herault, 2002), 268 pages, ISBN 978-2-7407-0180-5. Draws on previously unpublished documents on the relic's history between 1156 and 1486, and compares the Argenteuil tradition against the rival claim made for the Holy Robe of Trier.
Citation
AuthorPierre Dor
PublisherEditions Herault, Maulevrier
Publication Year2002
Source TypeMonograph
Cross-Tradition Connections
Associated With
This source names France directly: "history press in the Anjou region of France rather than a major academic publisher, and the author's independence from the Argenteuil parish that holds the relic has not been established by the..."
Trier, Cities This source names Trier directly: "rival claim made for the Holy Robe of Trier, the book's explicit second subject named in its own subtitle."
Claims Backed By This Source (15 claims)
This source backs 15 claims across the atlas. As facts: 9 well-attested, 1 scholarly debate. As cited relationships: 2 holds. Plus 3 entities citing it as a general reference with no single fact or relationship attached.
Disposition By Topic
- Sources, 9 claims: 7 well-attested, 2 holds.
- Sacred Sites, 3 claims: 2 well-attested, 1 general references.
- Artifacts & Relics, 2 claims: 1 scholarly debate, 1 general references.
- Articles, 1 claims: 1 general references.
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.
Sign in to dispute this or suggest a correction.
View At A Past Year
The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.