Wars & Conflicts
Irish Confederate Wars
Citation Formats
General Reference
APA Style
BibTeX
A multi-sided conflict, also called the Eleven Years War, that convulsed Ireland from the Ulster rising of October 1641 to the completion of the Cromwellian conquest in 1653. The Irish Catholic Confederation, formed at Kilkenny in 1642 by an alliance of Old English and Gaelic Irish Catholic gentry with Catholic clergy sitting in its General Assembly, fought English and Scottish Protestant Parliamentarian and later Commonwealth forces, Scottish Covenanter troops defending Ulster's Protestant settlers, and, for parts of the war, English royalist forces. The Confederation styled itself "Ireland's Catholic and Royal Army" and bound its members by the Oath of Association, swearing to defend the Catholic religion, the king's prerogative and Ireland's laws together; it later split between moderates seeking accommodation with the Protestant royalist Duke of Ormond and clerical hardliners around the papal nuncio Rinuccini demanding full Catholic religious restoration. Oliver Cromwell's 1649 to 1650 campaign broke organized Confederate resistance, and mopping-up fighting continued in the west until 1653.
Facts
Disputed
Death TollWilliam Petty's 1650s Down Survey, the era's only systematic contemporary count, put total deaths from war, famine and plague across 1641 to 1652 at not less than four hundred thousand. Lenihan and other modern historians still cite this as the traditional low bound even while treating Petty's own method, extrapolating from incomplete surveys and never separating war deaths from famine and plague mortality, as unreliable for a precise total. Death TollPetty's own upper estimate reached six hundred and twenty thousand, as much as two fifths of Ireland's pre-war population by some readings. Lenihan's own demographic scholarship, in his article "War and Population, 1649 to 52," argues this upper figure in particular overstates war-caused mortality, and no modern historian has produced a rival reconciled total that separates combat and massacre deaths from the era's simultaneous famine and plague. Religious DimensionThe Confederation bound its members by the Oath of Association, a specifically religious oath to defend the public and free exercise of the Catholic religion alongside the king's prerogative, and Catholic clergy sat as full members of its General Assembly; the papal nuncio Rinuccini's presence and his demand for full Catholic religious establishment as a condition of peace, which split the Confederation from within, underscore how far religion structured the conflict on the Catholic side. O Siochru's constitutional study nonetheless stresses the Confederation was never a simple Catholic crusade: its moderate faction, led by Nicholas Plunkett, was consistently willing to trade religious toleration for political accommodation with the Protestant royalist Ormond, and dynastic loyalty to Charles I and Old English constitutional grievance ran alongside religious motive throughout. 2 The Event
When It HappenedOctober 1641 to 1653, with the acute Cromwellian conquest phase from August 1649 to May 1650 1 Principal PartiesThe Irish Catholic Confederation, formed at Kilkenny in 1642 and led by an alliance of Old English and Gaelic Irish Catholic gentry with the Catholic clergy represented in its General Assembly, against English and Scottish Protestant Parliamentarian and later Commonwealth forces, Scottish Covenanter troops defending Ulster's Protestant settlers, and, for parts of the war, English royalist forces; the Confederation itself later split between a moderate faction seeking peace with the Protestant royalist Duke of Ormond and a clerical hardline faction around the papal nuncio Rinuccini. 2 Consequences
What It SettledOliver Cromwell's 1649 to 1650 campaign, marked by the storming of Drogheda and Wexford, broke organized Confederate resistance; mopping-up fighting continued in the west until 1653. The Cromwellian land settlement that followed confiscated most land still held by Irish Catholic owners and transplanted many to Connacht, remaking Ireland's landholding along confessional lines for more than two centuries, while the Catholic Church's public institutions were suppressed and priests made subject to banishment or execution under the Commonwealth regime. 1 Status
Official RecognitionNot formally recognized by any body 1 Recognition BasisNo international body existed to make a genocide or crimes against humanity determination in the seventeenth century, and no modern body has retrospectively classified the conflict as such; historians study it as a civil war and conquest rather than under that later legal vocabulary. 1 Learn More
The Irish Catholic Confederation and the Wars That Remade Ireland's Land
This article records tradition as it has been passed down and reported. Its sources are not yet part of the atlas's verified catalogue.
The Ulster rising of October 1641 opened a conflict, also called the Eleven Years War, that convulsed Ireland until the Cromwellian conquest was completed in 1653. The Irish Catholic Confederation, formed at Kilkenny in 1642 by an alliance of Old English and Gaelic Irish Catholic gentry with Catholic clergy sitting in its General Assembly, styled itself Ireland's Catholic and Royal Army and fought English and Scottish Protestant Parliamentarian and later Commonwealth forces, Scottish Covenanter troops defending Ulster's Protestant settlers, and, for parts of the war, English royalist forces.
Oliver Cromwell's 1649 to 1650 campaign, marked by the storming of Drogheda and Wexford, broke organized Confederate resistance, though mopping-up fighting continued in the west until 1653. The Cromwellian land settlement that followed confiscated most land still held by Irish Catholic owners and transplanted many to Connacht, remaking Ireland's landholding along confessional lines for more than two centuries, while the Catholic Church's public institutions were suppressed and priests made subject to banishment or execution under the Commonwealth regime.
An Unsettled Death Toll and a Confederation Split Over Faith
This article records tradition as it has been passed down and reported. Its sources are not yet part of the atlas's verified catalogue.
Historians place the Irish Confederate Wars' dead between four hundred thousand and six hundred twenty thousand, a range this atlas records as debated rather than settle on a single figure, since no reconciled study exists that bridges the wide estimates in the literature. The Confederation itself split internally over how far religion should govern its aims: a moderate faction seeking peace with the Protestant royalist Duke of Ormond against a clerical hardline faction around the papal nuncio Rinuccini, who demanded full Catholic religious restoration as a condition of any settlement.
The Confederation bound its members by the Oath of Association, a specifically religious oath to defend the public and free exercise of the Catholic religion alongside the king's prerogative, and Catholic clergy sat as full members of its General Assembly, evidence religion structured the conflict on the Catholic side. Yet O Siochru's constitutional study stresses the Confederation was never a simple Catholic crusade: its moderate faction, led by Nicholas Plunkett, was consistently willing to trade religious toleration for political accommodation with Ormond, and dynastic loyalty to Charles I and Old English constitutional grievance ran alongside religious motive throughout, so this atlas records the religious dimension as debated rather than singular.
Cross-Tradition Connections
Belongs to Tradition
The Parliamentarian and later Commonwealth forces that fought the Confederation, and the Scottish Covenanter troops defending Ulster's Protestant settlers, were themselves Protestant and, under Cromwell, suppressed Catholic public worship and banished or executed priests once the conquest was complete. Lenihan and O Siochru both treat this side's war aims as substantially constitutional and dynastic, contesting Parliament's and later the Commonwealth's authority over Ireland, so this edge connects that side to Protestant identity without asserting the faith alone directed its campaign.
The Confederation bound its own members by the Oath of Association, a religious oath to defend "the public and free exercise of the Roman Catholic and apostolic religion" alongside the king's prerogative, and seated Catholic clergy as full members of its governing General Assembly. This edge records the Confederation's own declared religious cause and structure exactly as O Siochru's constitutional study gives it, not a claim that the whole war was fought over doctrine alone.
Sources
Open Questions (1 open question)
What Was the Death Toll of the Irish Confederate Wars?
William Petty's 1650s Down Survey remains the era's only systematic contemporary count, and modern historians including Lenihan treat his method, extrapolating from incomplete surveys and combining combat, massacre, famine and plague deaths into one total, as unreliable for a precise war-specific figure without offering a reconciled alternative of their own.
What would resolve this A modern demographic reconstruction applying consistent method to seventeenth century Irish parish, estate and muster records, capable of separating combat and massacre deaths from the era's simultaneous, and largely coincidental, famine and plague mortality.
Early modern Irish history; historical demographyPadraig Lenihan, Confederate Catholics at War, 1641 to 1649
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.
Sign in to dispute this or suggest a correction.
View At A Past Year
The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.