Divinity Atlas

Sacred Correspondences
Practices

Confession

Purificatory Practices

Citation Formats

General Reference

APA Style

BibTeX

Origin 500 to 1215 CE

The acknowledgment of one's sins or faults, to God, to a priest, or before the community, in order to seek forgiveness and be reconciled. In Catholic and Orthodox Christianity it is a sacrament in which the penitent confesses privately to a priest and receives absolution; many Protestants confess directly to God or one another. Judaism confesses sins communally, above all on the Day of Atonement, and Buddhist monastics confess breaches of the rule at set assemblies. Confession names wrongdoing honestly rather than hiding it, expresses genuine sorrow and the resolve to amend, relieves the burden of guilt, restores broken relationship, and renews moral life.

Facts
Practice
Category of Practice
Confession, the acknowledgement of sin to God, often before a priest or the gathered community, is practised across Christian traditions in forms ranging from the private sacramental confession of Catholic and Orthodox practice to the general corporate confession of Protestant liturgy. 1
Who Performs It
Lay people 1
Frequency
Annual 1
At least once a year in Catholic canon law; in practice more often
Solitary or Communal
Performed by an officiant for a recipient 1
Origins
Origin Period
500 to 1215 CE 1
Origin Period
Private auricular confession spreads from Irish monastic practice and is required annually from 1215 1
Place of Origin
Ireland, in early medieval Irish monastic practice 1
Attributions
Tradition
Practiced most formally within Roman Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy as a sacrament, and less formally within other Christian traditions as a private acknowledgment of sin. 1
Status
Status Within the Tradition
Catholic and Orthodox Christianity hold it as one of the sacraments, in which a priest pronounces absolution; most Protestant traditions hold no such sacramental status and teach that confession is made directly to God or, at most, to one another. 1
Status Today
Living tradition, practised today 2
Scholarship and Forensics
Scholarly Note
Judaism practices confession communally rather than privately, most concentratedly on the Day of Atonement, and Buddhist monastics confess breaches of the monastic rule at set communal assemblies rather than to an individual confessor. 2
Learn More
Private, Communal, Monastic

Confession takes three broad forms, and they do different work.

Private confession is the Catholic and Orthodox practice: the penitent names particular sins to a priest, receives counsel and a penance, and is absolved. Catholic practice requires it for grave sin before receiving communion, and at minimum once a year. The physical arrangement is designed to keep the priest a witness rather than an audience, a screened box in the Latin tradition, and in Orthodox practice standing beside the priest facing an icon rather than facing him, so that both are turned toward the same thing.

Communal confession names wrongdoing collectively and without individuating it. Jewish liturgy on the Day of Atonement recites an alphabetical catalogue of transgressions in the first person plural, so that the entire congregation confesses everything on the list, including what most of them have not done. That is deliberate. It asserts collective responsibility and it removes any possibility of looking around the room to see who is confessing what. Protestant liturgies commonly include a general confession of the same shape.

Monastic confession is disciplinary rather than sacramental. The Buddhist monastic community assembles twice a month, at new and full moon, to recite the code of training rules, and monks are expected to have disclosed any breach beforehand; the recitation moves through the categories of offence with a pause after each for anyone to declare. This is among the oldest continuous institutional practices in any religion, and its purpose is the integrity of the community rather than the forgiveness of the individual, a genuinely different aim, and one worth not assimilating to the Christian model.

The Seal, and What It Costs

The confidentiality of confession is among the strongest secrecy obligations any institution places on its members, and it is currently under sustained pressure.

Catholic canon law makes the seal absolute. A priest may not reveal what he hears in confession for any reason whatever, including to prevent a crime, and breaking it incurs automatic excommunication reserved to Rome. There is no exception for grave crime, for a court order, or for the safety of a child. Priests have gone to prison rather than testify, and the church regards that as the correct outcome.

The pressure comes from child abuse inquiries. Australia's royal commission recommended in 2017 that clergy be required to report abuse disclosed in confession, and several Australian jurisdictions legislated to that effect; comparable proposals have been made in other countries since. The church's position has not moved, and bishops have stated publicly that priests will accept imprisonment rather than comply. Both positions are held sincerely, and neither has an obvious answer. The argument that the seal is what makes any disclosure possible in the first place is not frivolous. Nor is the observation that in practice it has protected offenders.

Other traditions meet the question in different shapes because they organise the practice differently. Protestant clergy are generally covered by a narrower statutory privilege that varies by jurisdiction and often carries explicit exceptions. Where confession is communal, or made directly to God without a human hearer, the problem does not arise in this form at all. That is not an accident of history so much as a consequence of who is standing there, and it is one of the clearest cases where the mechanics of a practice generate its legal difficulties.

Secular Descendants

Confession is the religious practice with the clearest secular successors, and the lineage is not merely a metaphor.

Psychoanalysis took the structure and changed the theory. A person speaks at length about themselves to a trained listener who does not judge, in a fixed setting, at regular intervals, under confidentiality, and the speaking is itself held to be curative. The debt to the confessional was noticed early and usually by critics, and the analytic tradition has been ambivalent about the comparison ever since. The differences are real: no absolution is offered, and the material sought is what the speaker does not know about themselves rather than what they are concealing. The form is nonetheless recognisable at a glance.

Twelve-step programmes are more explicit about it. The fourth and fifth steps require a searching moral inventory and then the admission of its exact nature to God, to oneself, and to another human being. The programme began in an evangelical Christian context and kept the shape while making the theology optional, which is why it transplants so readily.

Truth commissions apply the same logic to a whole society. South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission granted amnesty in exchange for full disclosure of politically motivated crimes: confession with absolution attached, made public rather than private, and administered by a state. It was criticised on precisely the grounds religious confession has always been criticised, that it can substitute for restitution and let the guilty settle too cheaply.

The comparative point is that the underlying claim, that saying the thing out loud to another person changes something, has outlived the theology that once justified it, and has been rebuilt from scratch by people who would not describe themselves as religious at all.

Cross-Tradition Connections

Belongs to Tradition

Kept across the provinces of the Anglican Communion. Anglicanism keeps auricular confession available but not required, summarised in the maxim that all may, none must, some should; a general confession said by the whole congregation is the ordinary form.

Anglicanism keeps auricular confession available but not required, summarised in the maxim that all may, none must, some should; a general confession said by the whole congregation is the ordinary form.

Source The Holy BibleAnonymous (multiple authors)

Kept in the Armenian Apostolic Church. The Coptic and other Oriental churches keep private confession to a priest, with the Coptic practice of a father of confession, a single priest to whom a person confesses habitually, and absolution before receiving the sacrament.

Confession is practised, and the East Syriac tradition developed its penitential discipline separately from both the Byzantine and the Latin.

Buddhism, Religions
Source Encyclopedia of ReligionMircea Eliade (ed.); Lindsay Jones (ed., 2nd ed.)
Source Encyclopedia of ReligionMircea Eliade (ed.); Lindsay Jones (ed., 2nd ed.)

Kept in the Church of Cyprus, autocephalous since the Council of Ephesus in 431. The Orthodox confess standing beside the priest before an icon rather than through a grille, the priest understood as a witness rather than a judge, and confession is ordinarily expected before receiving communion.

Kept in the Church of England, the province from which the Prayer Book tradition comes. Anglicanism keeps auricular confession available but not required, summarised in the maxim that all may, none must, some should; a general confession said by the whole congregation is the ordinary form.

Kept in the Church of Greece. The Orthodox confess standing beside the priest before an icon rather than through a grille, the priest understood as a witness rather than a judge, and confession is ordinarily expected before receiving communion.

Kept in the Church of Ireland. Anglicanism keeps auricular confession available but not required, summarised in the maxim that all may, none must, some should; a general confession said by the whole congregation is the ordinary form.

Kept in the Church of Sweden, which retained the historic episcopate through the Reformation as few Lutheran churches did. Luther retained private confession and absolution and defended it in the catechisms, though the practice fell away in most Lutheran churches in favour of a corporate confession at the start of the service.

Kept in the Coptic Orthodox Church of Alexandria. The Coptic and other Oriental churches keep private confession to a priest, with the Coptic practice of a father of confession, a single priest to whom a person confesses habitually, and absolution before receiving the sacrament.

The Orthodox confess standing beside the priest before an icon rather than through a grille, the priest understood as a witness rather than a judge, and confession is ordinarily expected before receiving communion.

Source The Holy BibleAnonymous (multiple authors)

Kept in the Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople, the see of first honour among the Orthodox churches. The Orthodox confess standing beside the priest before an icon rather than through a grille, the priest understood as a witness rather than a judge, and confession is ordinarily expected before receiving communion.

Kept in the Eritrean Orthodox Tewahedo Church. The Coptic and other Oriental churches keep private confession to a priest, with the Coptic practice of a father of confession, a single priest to whom a person confesses habitually, and absolution before receiving the sacrament.

Kept in the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church. The Coptic and other Oriental churches keep private confession to a priest, with the Coptic practice of a father of confession, a single priest to whom a person confesses habitually, and absolution before receiving the sacrament.

Kept in the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. Luther retained private confession and absolution and defended it in the catechisms, though the practice fell away in most Lutheran churches in favour of a corporate confession at the start of the service.

Kept in the Georgian Orthodox Church, which has used its own language and script in worship since the fifth century. The Orthodox confess standing beside the priest before an icon rather than through a grille, the priest understood as a witness rather than a judge, and confession is ordinarily expected before receiving communion.

Kept in the Greek Orthodox churches. The Orthodox confess standing beside the priest before an icon rather than through a grille, the priest understood as a witness rather than a judge, and confession is ordinarily expected before receiving communion.

Luther retained private confession and absolution and defended it in the catechisms, though the practice fell away in most Lutheran churches in favour of a corporate confession at the start of the service.

Source The Holy BibleAnonymous (multiple authors)

Confession is kept as one of the mysteries.

Confession is kept, and in the priestless communities it is heard by a lay elder because there is no priest to hear it.

The Coptic and other Oriental churches keep private confession to a priest, with the Coptic practice of a father of confession, a single priest to whom a person confesses habitually, and absolution before receiving the sacrament.

Source The Holy BibleAnonymous (multiple authors)

Catholics confess privately to a priest, who absolves under an absolute seal of secrecy, and the church obliges the confession of grave sin at least once a year; a penance is assigned, and indulgences are attached to the sacrament.

Source The Holy BibleAnonymous (multiple authors)

Kept in the Romanian Orthodox Church, the one Orthodox church of the Byzantine tradition whose language is Romance. The Orthodox confess standing beside the priest before an icon rather than through a grille, the priest understood as a witness rather than a judge, and confession is ordinarily expected before receiving communion.

Kept in the Russian Orthodox Church, in the Slavonic recension of the Byzantine books. The Orthodox confess standing beside the priest before an icon rather than through a grille, the priest understood as a witness rather than a judge, and confession is ordinarily expected before receiving communion.

Kept in the Serbian Orthodox Church. The Orthodox confess standing beside the priest before an icon rather than through a grille, the priest understood as a witness rather than a judge, and confession is ordinarily expected before receiving communion.

Shakers, Denominations

Confession of sin to an elder of one's own sex was required before a person could be received into the community.

Kept in the Episcopal Church, whose own Prayer Book descends from the Scottish rather than the English line. Anglicanism keeps auricular confession available but not required, summarised in the maxim that all may, none must, some should; a general confession said by the whole congregation is the ordinary form.

Confession follows the Byzantine form, the penitent standing beside the priest before an icon rather than kneeling in an enclosed box.

Kept in the Ukrainian Orthodox Church. The Orthodox confess standing beside the priest before an icon rather than through a grille, the priest understood as a witness rather than a judge, and confession is ordinarily expected before receiving communion.

Element Of

Kept where the movement's host church keeps it, since the movement adds to a church's practice rather than replacing it.

Related To

The ordinary remedy for mortal sin, which the Council of Trent required to be confessed by kind and by number.

Confession within this frame is diagnosis before a physician rather than sentence before a judge.

Sources
1. The Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church, 3rd revised edition
F. L. Cross and E. A. Livingstone (eds.), Oxford University Press, 2005View the Source
2. Encyclopedia of Religion
Mircea Eliade (ed.); Lindsay Jones (ed., 2nd ed.), Macmillan Reference, 2005View the Source
The Holy Bible
Anonymous (multiple authors), Robert Barker, 1611James 5:16; 1 John 1:9View the Source
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.

View At A Past Year

Choose a year to see this entry's facts and connections as the atlas records them at that moment: what it held then, what it held instead, and what it had not yet adopted. Choose Present for the current record.